Wrought iron
rod fences have a timeless appeal, while newer vinyl fences don't need as much maintenance.
When Robert Frost wrote that good fences make good neighbors, vinyl fences were still decades away from existence, but centuries-old wrought iron fencing enclosed everything from front yards to cemeteries. Today, both types of fencing have advantages and disadvantages that are related to cost, maintenance and aesthetic factors. Does this Spark an idea?
Vinyl Fences
Vinyl fences never need painting and resist peeling, decay and rust, making them a low-maintenance alternative to wood and metal fences. Vinyl fencing cannot be harmed by wood-boring insects, and their color generally doesn't fade from direct sunlight. The fences often come with lifetime warranties that sometimes can be transferred to a new owner when the house is sold. Vinyl fencing is available in many styles, from ones that mimic wood picket fencing to taller, solid privacy fencing. Some feature a wood-grain finish.
Wrought Iron Fences
Wrought iron fences can be found most often on the grounds of historic properties with early American or Victorian buildings. Newer wrought-iron-style fences are made from aluminum or steel, making them lighter and more flexible. Wrought iron fences offer more opportunities for decorative elements, from diamonds to fleur-de-lis, than vinyl fences. Graffiti is less a concern with wrought iron fencing, but the design provides less privacy than vinyl fences.
Cost
In general, vinyl fences cost less than wrought iron, but the price depends on the brand and style of fencing purchased, as well as installation. As of November 2011, you can expect to pay from $2,142 to $2,682 for 150 linear feet of vinyl fencing, according to home improvement website homewyse. This does not include installation, which can vary widely depending on the company used and area of the country in which you live. The same amount of wrought iron fencing will cost between $2,817 and $4,040.
Durability and Maintainence
Unlike wood, vinyl fences do not require painting or staining, nor do they peel or chip. Many companies advertise them as maintenance-free. You can use a hose to wash off dirt and debris when needed. Although vinyl is less flexible in cold temperatures, it does not break or crack unless it is hit with significant force, such as by a car. Wrought iron fences can rust and the paint can peel, so they require more upkeep. Rust-inhibiting exterior paint can add life to the fence. Individual rods can be replaced if they are damaged. With proper maintenance, wrought iron fences can last more than a century.
Tags: vinyl fences, iron fences, iron fencing, wrought iron, wrought iron fencing
